Batgirl #1 Thoughts (Minor Spoilers)



Writer: Gail Simone
Artist: Ardian Syaf

The most controversial book in the relaunch, and unfortunately proof that from the very beginning Dan Didio kind of wanted to return all the comic characters to who they were in the 60's. Well, now that it's here, how does it stack up?

Well, to be honest...pretty decently, if not perfectly. Simone shows us a Batgirl who (rightfully) suffers from Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder, but who also refuses to give up being a hero when there are people she can help. It's a good opening issue--showing us who Barbara Gordon is, what she was and hopes to become again. It introduces a supporting cast, a main villain, and gives our hero a base of operations. (Actually, very few comics managed to accomplished all this in this New 52, now that I think about it...)

The problem--if there must be one--is that this was a project Gail took out of...I want to say, responsibility. Any hardcore comic fan that isn't a mindless fanboy knows that Gail initially didn't want this project. And probably would prefer if Barbara were still Oracle*, and Bryan Q. Miller was writing Stephanie Brown as Batgirl while she did Firestorm and something Captain Marvel or Plastic Man-related.

But this was something that DC was going to make happen. So she wanted the chance to do it right. And I'm guessing (admittedly I could be wrong) that that's why some bits and pieces seem...wrong? Gail's a fantastic writer, and it shows but there are awkward bits of dialogue here and there (particularly when she's Batgirl**) and the climax of the issue feels...forced? I guess that's the best way to put it.

But I have faith in her to bring this series up to the same level Bryan Q. Miller did, and thankfully she already has a great artist to keep the book looking amazing while she does. Looking forward to the next issue.

* A quick note about Oracle: After Gail's recent "Death of Oracle" plotline there was absolutely no reason to keep her in the wheelchair. She's "more useful" as Oracle? Really? Gail killed the concept of Oracle off in the DCU, so basically she was only helping a handful of people. The only reason left to keep her in the wheelchair was to keep her as a role model. A valid reason, but when every male superhero that's ever been put in a wheelchair is now walking while the most well-known female superhero isn't? Do we really want to send that kind of statement?


** It occurs to me the Barbara Gordon dialogue sounded much more natural and like the character Gail Simone's been writing for ages now. Maybe the Batgirl dialogue is Babs putting on a show or adopting a stronger persona to deal with what happened to her? If so, then that's a brilliant way of showing how there's no way such a traumatic event would be so easily shrugged off.

The last thing I want to talk about is the fact that Gail didn't cover just exactly HOW Barbara started walking again. This left many readers dissatisfied, but the truth is...there's no possible answer that would've satisfied everyone. The answer that we're given, in that case, works as well as any other. (The truth is: DC wanted her to, and obviously that answer can't be used here.)

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Sage Spoils The Plot: Kamen Rider Decade

Image
Starting a new section today, entitled Sage Spoils The Plot. I pondered over this name for quite a while, but as I thought about it, I realized calling it commentary or blogging or whatever is just bullshit. What you're REALLY doing is spoiling the plot and adding your own brand of shitty humor. So, why not be honest? Plus, Sage Spoils The Plot has kind of a ring to it. For the first section we're doing the new Kamen Rider series of 2009, Kamen Rider Decade. Kamen Rider checks a lot of "totally fucking awesome" boxes for me. A lot of people might call it, "Japanese Power Rangers" (which is untrue from the start since that already exists) due to the suits and the fight scenes. I accept this. That said, its proof that anything done right can be cool--so when you get rid of the over-acting, toss in a good plot (exceptionally good plots actually), add in some well done characterization, and tone down the stupid-level of the fight scenes and make them look less l
Read more

The New 52, Corrected: Justice Legion A

Image
What Happened: It’s another replacement book.  This time we’re getting rid of Legion Lost.  What I’d Change: Enjoy the adventures of the Justice League of the 853rd century.  Why: Put simply?  Legion Lost didn’t have enough legs to function as an ongoing series.  A group of the Legion’s best members go to the past to combat an alien virus...and then what.  They get stuck?  Meh.  The appeal of the Legion is they’re from the future.  This could have been a great MINI-series; something with a beginning, a middle, and an end.  As an ongoing I got bored, really fast.  So instead let’s replace them with a book about the Justice League of the far future. DC's got a terrible habit of making up awesome concepts and then leaving them by the wayside, this is one of DC’s greatest and its only been revisited like, twice.  (Once by Geoff Johns with Booster Gold 1,000,000 and once with Chris Roberson with some Superman/Batman comic.)   It helps lighten the hit that came with Flashpoint
Read more